Browse all of our lovingly handmade flavors!
Our fresh, hand-crafted flavors are available in 6 pint quantities.
We welcome you to browse through our flavor selection and send a gift to a faraway friend or family member, or treat yourself to the taste of freshly-made, delicious Gibby’s original recipes delivered from our home to your doorstep! Enjoy!
Cherry Vanilla
Velvety vanilla ice cream blended with mouth-watering Bordeaux cherries. This one is a classic!
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Fresh vanilla bean ice cream packed with chocolate chip cookie dough pieces and semi-sweet chocolate chunks in every bite.
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Decadent chocolate and peanut butter ice cream that tastes just like a smooth, creamy chocolate peanut butter cup.
Coffee
Our customers describe our Coffee ice cream as rich and bold, but not overwhelming. It is creamy, balanced, and just really delicious. Even those who don’t drink coffee love this old-school treat.
Cookies n Cream
Rich cream base loaded with Oreo cookie chunks for a crunchy treat!
Egg Nog
Just like the real thing! This is the secret weapon of holiday desserts. Try some with your pumpkin pie or sprinkle it with nutmeg. Delicious!
Mint Chocolate Chip
Our most popular flavor! Real cream flavor with a zing of mint and crunchy bits of chocolate that melts in your mouth.
Peanut Butter Chipple
This is heaven for peanut butter lovers. We start with smooth, creamy, peanut butter ice cream, then we mix in tons of peanut butter chips for extra peanut butter flavor and a satisfying crunch.
Peppermint Stick
This limited-time, seasonal flavor is a candy cane lover’s dream! We start with smooth peppermint-y ice cream and blend in crushed candy canes. Fresh, festive, and perfect for the holidays!
Pumpkin
This seasonal favorite infuses traditional pumpkin, clove, nutmeg and cinnamon flavors for a cool, creamy fall treat.
Salty Caramel
Here’s your sweet and salty fix! A perfect blend of these complex flavors for a smooth, creamy treat.
Strawberry Cheesecake
Rich New York cheesecake ice cream swirled with a ribbon of strawberry that is sweet and tart for a burst of flavor in your mouth.
Teaberry
This is a classic Pennsylvania flavor brought to Gibby’s by my Dad, the founder of the store. Teaberry is sweet, a touch tart, and tastes much like wintergreen. An old-timey favorite!
